For Editors

The editorial role at Shiharr Publishing: responsibilities, peer review management and the standards we hold to.

Home / For Editors

Editorial responsibilities

  • Handle manuscripts in the section you are assigned to, from first assessment to final decision.
  • Make decisions on the evidence in the reviews, not on the reputation of authors or institutions.
  • Keep authors informed and keep the review timeline realistic; escalate delays to the editor-in-chief.
  • Commission or solicit content where the journal's scope would otherwise leave a gap.

Managing peer review

  • Screen submissions for scope, completeness and ethics compliance before inviting reviewers.
  • Invite at least two independent reviewers who have no competing interest in the work.
  • Resolve conflicting reviews by reading the manuscript yourself and, where needed, inviting a third opinion.
  • Ensure that rejected manuscripts are not re-reviewed after only cosmetic changes.

Publication ethics

  • Follow COPE guidance on authorship disputes, plagiarism, duplicate submission and data fabrication.
  • Require corrections, expressions of concern or retractions where the record demands it, and link them to the original article.
  • Protect reviewer and author confidentiality, and disclose your own competing interests.
  • Never submit your own work to a journal you edit; route handling to an independent editor.

Tools and training

  • Editorial work happens in the journal's online system: submissions, reviews, decisions and issues are all recorded there.
  • Templates exist for decision letters, reviewer invitations and issue front matter.
  • New editors receive an induction session and a written handbook; ongoing training is offered annually.

Joining an editorial team

  • Editorial positions are open to researchers with a record of peer review and clear subject expertise.
  • Expressions of interest should include a CV, a short statement of interest and preferred section.
  • Appointments are made for a renewable three-year term by the publisher with the editor-in-chief.